I picked up Slave Labor Graphics's comics title, Wonderland number one, not sure whether I would like it or not. I had previously bought the first two issues of one of SLG's other Disney series,The Haunted Mansion , and had decided not to keep buying it. But I purchased Wonderland largely based on the fact that Tommy Kovac's name was attached to it.
Being a Southern California gal, I have an affection for all things Disney. At this point in my life, I feel this to be an unjustifiable and unruly passion. Nonetheless, I am reconciled to the fact that there are some things about one self that one cannot change. Some things must be lived and suffered. So it is with my love of Disney.
I say all this mainly to let you know that I bought The Haunted Mansion comic book with the expectation and hope that I would enjoy reading it. I had a vague idea that this comic was part of Disney's general effort to extend their brand and sub-brands in every which way possible. Thus, movies become soundtracks become toys become cartoons become parades become rides become comics. Or some variation of that sequence.
On the site Haunted Mansion Secrets, you can read differing opinions about whether the Haunted Mansion ride was originally intended to tell a story or not. It certainly seems, based on the accounts on this page, that there were once some story ideas kicking around that may not have made it to the final ride. Although certain characters, rooms and scenarios suggest story fragments, these stories may have been added later to enhance a staged effect, rather than serving as a starting point.
This lack of story in the Haunted Mansion ride presents a problem for adaptation. In the first story of issue one of the Haunted Mansion comic, the story is actually not a story at all, but the voiceover from the ride itself, illustrated. If you are a ride aficionado, there is some pleasure in simply reading the lines. As someone who writes for a living, I was actually amazed at the complexity of the language in this speech, compared to that in present day entertainments.
Nonetheless, it wasn't really a story. And as I got further in the book, the same problem kept arising. Cleave too close to the ride and there's no real storyline; create a real story with complex characters, and you start to lose touch with the ride.
Wonderland is an interesting contrast, because its origin point is a book, which the Disney movie adaptation is based on, which then became the basis for the ride. I found Wonderland a better read, perhaps because of the literary reference point. There was a story behind the story, so to speak. The artwork in Wonderland is also incredibly fluid and dynamic, and aids the movement of the story considerably. Disneyland's Alice in Wonderland ride is a classic, but I'm glad it wasn't the basis for this title.